Malaysiakini - A SHOCKING FIND. TERESA KOK NOT GUILTY. PART 6

Please refer the previous article before any reading being done.

Sunday, September 14, 2008 1 ) Malaysiakini : Live Video Teresa's Parents Outcry.

Monday, September 15, 2008 2 ) Malaysiakini : A SHOCKING FIND. TERESA KOK NOT GUILTY. PART 2 (Part 1 and Part 2 Join Together)

Monday, September 15, 2008 3 ) Malaysiakini : A SHOCKING FIND. TERESA KOK NOT GUILTY. PART 3

Tuesday, September 16, 2008 4 ) Malaysiakini : A SHOCKING FIND. TERESA KOK NOT GUILTY. PART 4

Wednesday, September 17, 2008 5 ) Malaysiakini : A SHOCKING FIND. TERESA KOK NOT GUILTY. PART 5

PART 6 will be continue ..............

Who was supposed to be blamed ? Residents of Bandar Kinrara, Section 5 ? YB Mohamad Satim Diman ? MP Teresa Kok ? The mosque ? Pembelamelayu Blogspot ? Datuk Seri Dr. Mohamed Khir Toyo ? Zaini Hassan - the Award Winner senior editor ? Utusan Malaysia ? The Police ? Home Minister - Syed Hamid Albar ? Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi or the governments of MALAYSIA...... Barisan Nasional ?

Let us find out in detail who is supposed to be blamed for this kind of mess ?

1 ) Residents of Bandar Kinrara, Section 5.

It all started back in February 2008 with a petition from the Residents’ Association, Bandar Kinrara Section 5 , Puchong, Selangor to the local mosque which was actually a request to lower the volume of the ceramah (religious talks) signed by about 189 residents.

The residents stated that the loudspeakers of the mosque where its ceramah (religious talks), kuliah subuh (religious lectures at dawn) and kuliah maghrib (religious lectures at dusk), have disturbed their peace at a time when they were resting or sleeping late, especially on Sundays - as early as 6:15am - and during those evenings when they were tutoring their children.

So, they write a letter to YB Mohamad Satim Diman (Serdang state assemblyperson ) in the hope that YB Satim would understand their situation. With this, they seek YB Satim assistance to plead with the mosque management so as not to use the loudspeakers during its ceramah, kuliah subuh and kuliah maghrib, especially in the early morning or evening.

During that time February 2008, Barisan Nasional was still in power in Selangor and Khir Toyo was still the Menteri Besar.

The petition, signed by 189 residents, was handed over to YB Mohamad Satim Diman from Umno in February and another copy given to the mosque authorities. Another copy was also sent to Kinrara DAP state assemblyperson and state exco Teresa Kok’s office after the March 8 polls.

They just concern about the use of loudspeakers during religious ceramah that could go on for more than an hour and the residents who signed the petition said they had never intended to protest against the use of loudspeakers for the azan.

Instead they have requested the mosque to lower the volume of the loudspeakers for the ceramah (religious talks) which often followed the prayers.

From this point of views, indeed the residents' has nothing to do with this case as they just send a petition letter requesting YB Mohamad Satim to help them and the worst is when they send a copy of this letter to MP Teresa Kok, they didn't meet her to acknowledge her about this matter. The staff at Teresa Kok office did receive this letter without acknowledge her about this matter.

Now who was supposed to be blamed ?

2 ) YB Mohamad Satim Diman (Serdang state assemblyperson)

I don't know whether YB Satim was the one who supposed to be blame ? Why ? Based on the forum that appear in myKmu.net it sounds like that :

"At a functions held recently, a Barisan Nasional state assembly person said that during a state assembly meeting, YB Teresa Kok lead a petition drive on behalf of residents of Puchong to Datuk Satim Diman about a complaint that the morning Azan call had 'disturbed' the peace.

Umno state legislators seeking to protest the petition were ordered to remain seated, while Muslim legislators from Pakatan sat quietly and did not debate the issue."

That happen during Jun 24, 2008. The question is, who is that "wakil rakyat (BN)" in that forum that given out the speech. Whether this "wakil rakyat" during his speech, did he mention lower the volume of ceramah or lower the volume of Azan ? Or maybe this guy in the forum by the name of "detgeneration" heard it wrongly or the other way round ?

Or maybe YB Mohamad Satim mention it wrongly to this "wakil rakyat". Or maybe YB Mohamad Satim mention it correctly but because of this "wakil rakyat" looking for popularity during his speech he twisted the statement given by YB Mohamad Satim ?

Or maybe YB Mohamad Satim misunderstand and thought that lowering the volume of the loudspeakers for ceramah (religious talk) also including Azan prayers because inside the letter the resident's didn't mention about maintain the volume of loudspeakers during Azan prayes..

Now who was supposed to be blamed ?


3 ) Member of Parliament - YB Teresa Kok

At first she got nothing to do with this issue. Problem start to arise when she was been accused of being the lead members who leads one group of residents in Puchong to make a petition and hand it over to YB Mohamad Satim Diman.

During a by-election in Permatang Pauh, YB Teresa Kok knew there was an e-mails circulating around accusing her of being the lead member who send the petition to YB Mohamad Satim. At that time YB Teresa Kok didn't bother about this matter as this is just a political move to gain some votes at Permatang Pauh by-election.

When the e-mail starts circulating around, it reaches to some of state assemblyperson and a few of the journalist. They find it very interesting about this matter and ask YB Teresa Kok about her opinion ?

Meanwhile a blogsite (pembelamelayu Blogspot) has quoted Khir on June 26 as alleging that YB Teresa Kok had submitted a petition to Umno’s Seri Serdang state assemblyperson YB Satim which supposedly described the azans as “disturbing the peace” of local residents in Puchong.

YB Teresa Kok denied it and even issue a statement pertaining to this matter. She even ask the journalist to go and ask YB Mohamad Satim to produce the proof of her involvement and a petition letter send by her to him.

UMNO Selangor Memutar-belitkan Isu Azan di Puchong September 10th, 2008 by Teresa

But YB Mohamad Satim can't even produce the proof when was ask to show it by the journalist.


During her denial and accusation, YB Teresa Kok didn't know that her office did received a petition letter from the residents of Bandar Kinrara. Only when the news published in the newspaper, she only realize when the residents there fax a letter to her office.

Now why YB Teresa Kok staff didn't inform her in the first place about the petition letter when the resident's in Bandar Kinrara send to her office for acknowledgement ? At least YB Teresa Kok knows how to deal this matter accordingly or maybe YB Teresa Kok really know about this letter but forget to deal and attend this matter (during that time maybe she was so happy celebrating Pakatan wining in this general election).

Or maybe her staff didn't even know that this matter will become a big issue and just sign as a acknowlegment letter and put it a side? Who was that person who started to circulate an emial about the wrong doing of YB Teresa Kok ?

Now who was supposed to be blamed ?

4 ) The mosque.

Masjid Bandar Kinrara is a It is about a few kilometres from Astro and Technology Park Malaysia. Just nearby the Bandar Kinrara Golf Course, Puchong.


Former Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Dr. Khir Toyo, alleged that Teresa Kok had organised a petition against mosque officials in certain surau and masjid around Selangor to lower the volume of the azan prayer at the mosque. His comments appeared in Pembelamelayu Blogspot.

The chairman Abdul Rahman Nasir of Masjid Bandar Kinrara said he did receive the petition letter from the residents but said that MP Teresa Kok had never set foot ... to present the petition.

Before this allegation happen, Steven Ee, the person who presented the mosque with the petition on behalf of the residents said that he noticed that the loudspeakers volume was lowered for about two weeks after he presented the petition but then returned to its original pitch after that.


Now the question is why Masjid Bandar Kinrara after lowering the loudspeakers volume for two weeks and then returned to its original pitch ? Was the commitee member there been inform about this matter ? Or the commitee member being lambasted by the muslim residents for lowering the volume ? Or maybe they already forgotten about the petition letter ?

In the first place if they maintain the loudspeakers volume during azan prayers and lowering it down the loudspeakers volume during religious talk then this thing won't happen at all ?

Now who was supposed to be blamed ?

PART 7 will be continue ........

Anyway thanks to http://bangmalaysia.wordpress.com/ for sharing his article of "Proof of Innocence."

Teresa Kok - Proof of Innocence I - Malaysiakini

Teresa Kok - Proof of Innocence II - Malaysiakini

Teresa Kok - Proof of Innocence III - Malaysiakini

Teresa Kok - Proof of Innocence IV ~ Malaysiakini

Teresa Kok - Proof of Innocence V ~ref~ Malaysiakini